Work permit refusals and problems: a lawyer in Brampton
Updated
The short answer
Manny Hundal acts when a work permit is refused, when IRCC sends a procedural fairness letter (a letter from IRCC explaining a concern and giving you a chance to answer before it decides), when you are accused of misrepresentation, or when you lose status. Work permit refusals have no tribunal appeal, but judicial review at the Federal Court may be possible. The leave application is due within 15 days for decisions made in Canada and 60 days for decisions made outside Canada. Many people file a first work permit application on their own.
When you need a lawyer
Most work permit applications are paperwork, and many people file them on their own or with a licensed consultant. A lawyer is worth calling when something has gone wrong:
- Your work permit, extension or post-graduation work permit (PGWP) was refused
- IRCC sent a procedural fairness letter raising concerns about your job offer, your experience or your documents
- The officer suggests misrepresentation, for example about a job offer, a reference letter or a past refusal
- Your status expired, you worked without authorization, or you are relying on maintained status (the right to keep working while IRCC decides an extension you applied for in time) and something went wrong
- Your employer was found non-compliant, or your LMIA or job offer was questioned
- You have a criminal record or past immigration problem that makes you inadmissible
- You need a decision challenged at the Federal Court, where only a lawyer can represent you, except in rare cases the court allows
How Manny helps
Manny Hundal is a Barrister & Solicitor, called to the Ontario Bar in 2013. His practice is focused on immigration law. He works on the part of a work permit file that needs a lawyer:
- Reviewing the refusal. He reads the refusal letter, the officer decision note and, where useful, your GCMS notes, and tells you which options are open and which deadlines apply.
- Responding to procedural fairness letters. A fairness letter is your chance to answer the officer before a decision. He drafts the response and the supporting evidence.
- Defending against misrepresentation allegations. A finding can bar you from Canada for five years, so the response matters.
- Federal Court judicial review. Work permit refusals have no appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division. Judicial review at the Federal Court may be possible. He prepares and files the leave application and argues the case if leave is granted. See Federal Court judicial review.
- Status problems. He advises on restoration, on the risks of leaving Canada while on maintained status, and, where the facts support it, on a humanitarian and compassionate application.
- Inadmissibility. Where a criminal record or a past finding is the real issue, see inadmissibility.
Consultations are available in English, Punjabi and Hindi at the chambers in downtown Brampton. No lawyer can promise a result. This page is general information, not legal advice about your situation.
Deadlines
Judicial review (IRPA section 72)
the leave application must be filed and served within 15 days for a decision made in Canada, such as a refused extension or PGWP, or 60 days for a decision made outside Canada. The clock starts the day after you are notified of the decision or otherwise become aware of it.
Restoration
if your status has expired, you may be able to apply to restore it within 90 days, but you cannot work until restoration is approved.
Procedural fairness letters
the letter sets its own deadline. Respond within it, or ask in writing for more time before it passes.
Asking IRCC to reconsider does not stop the judicial review clock.
Who this is for
This page is for workers and graduates in Peel whose work permit file has run into trouble, and for employers whose hire was refused. The main types of work permit are:
LMIA-based work permits
The employer first gets a positive Labour Market Impact Assessment from Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC), and the worker then applies for a permit tied to that employer.
LMIA-exempt work permits
Some jobs do not need an LMIA, for example under trade agreements or intra-company transfers. The employer usually submits an offer through IRCC’s employer portal.
Open work permits
These include the PGWP, permits for some spouses and common-law partners, and permits for some people waiting for a permanent residence decision.
How it works
- The category is identified. It decides what the employer must do, what you must prove and how long the permit can last.
- Employer steps, if any. An LMIA application to ESDC, or an offer in the IRCC employer portal.
- The application is filed, usually online, with biometrics and a medical exam where required.
- Decision. An approval inside Canada is mailed. An approval from outside Canada comes as a letter for the border.
If you apply to extend before your permit expires and stay in Canada, you can usually keep working under the same conditions while IRCC decides. This is called maintained status.
Rules that often cause refusals
Low-wage LMIAs in the Toronto area
ESDC will not process low-wage LMIAs in census metropolitan areas with unemployment of 6% or higher. Its current list, for applications submitted from October 9, 2026 to January 7, 2027, includes Toronto, and Brampton is part of the Toronto census metropolitan area.
Spousal open work permits
Since January 21, 2025, these are generally limited to spouses of workers in TEER 0 or 1 occupations or selected TEER 2 or 3 occupations, with at least 16 months left on the worker’s permit, and to spouses of students in master’s programs of 16 months or longer, doctoral programs and certain professional programs. Dependent children of workers no longer qualify under this policy.
The PGWP
As of IRCC’s June 2026 eligibility page, you generally need an eligible program of at least eight months, an application within 180 days of completing it, CLB 7 (university) or CLB 5 (college and other) language results, and, for some non-degree programs, an eligible field of study. You can only receive one PGWP.
Documents you'll typically need
Timelines
Processing times and fees change often, so this page does not quote them. Check the IRCC processing times tool and the IRCC fee list. Court deadlines are fixed in law and run whether or not you have your file yet.
Common reasons work permits are refused
- Wrong category, often because the rules changed
- The job and your experience do not match
- Doubts you will leave at the end of your stay
- Employer problems, such as a non-compliant employer or a job offer that is not genuine
- Missed deadlines, such as a PGWP filed after 180 days or an extension filed after expiry
- Inadmissibility, including past misrepresentation
Frequently asked questions
Start with the reasons. Read the refusal letter and the officer decision note that IRCC now includes with most temporary resident refusals. Then choose a route. If the problem was missing evidence, a new application that fixes it may be the practical answer. If the officer ignored evidence, misread the facts or treated you unfairly, judicial review at the Federal Court may be possible. There is no tribunal appeal for work permit refusals. The leave application is due within 15 days if the decision was made in Canada and 60 days if it was made outside Canada, so get advice in the first few days. If your status is also affected, ask about restoration at the same time.
Not yet. A procedural fairness letter tells you the officer has concerns and gives you a chance to answer them before a decision is made. Common concerns are whether your job offer is genuine, whether your experience matches the job, or whether a document is authentic. Treat it as seriously as a refusal, because the response is often your only chance to put evidence and explanation on the record. Respond within the deadline in the letter. If misrepresentation is raised, the stakes are higher: a finding can bar you from Canada for five years.
Not always. Many employer-specific work permits need a positive LMIA from ESDC. But some jobs are exempt, for example under international trade agreements, intra-company transfers and some reciprocal youth programs. If an exemption applies, the employer still has to submit an offer of employment through IRCC’s employer portal and pay a compliance fee. Getting the category wrong is a frequent reason for refusal.
Right now, probably not. ESDC refuses to process low-wage LMIA applications in census metropolitan areas where unemployment is 6% or higher, and Toronto is on the list for applications submitted from October 9, 2026 to January 7, 2027. The list is updated every three months. Some sectors and situations are exempt, and high-wage LMIAs are not affected by this rule. An employer considering an LMIA should check the current list and wage threshold before advertising.
You may be, if you meet all the current requirements. You need a program of at least eight months at a PGWP-eligible school, full-time study, an application within 180 days of finishing, and language results of at least CLB 5 in all four skills. If you applied for your study permit on or after November 1, 2024, your program must also be in an eligible field of study. You can only get one PGWP. If your PGWP was refused on an application made in Canada, the 15-day judicial review deadline applies.
Possibly. Since January 21, 2025, family open work permits are generally limited to spouses and common-law partners of workers in TEER 0 or 1 occupations, or in selected TEER 2 or 3 occupations in sectors IRCC lists, such as health care and construction. The worker generally needs at least 16 months remaining on their permit when the spouse applies. Dependent children of workers are no longer eligible under this policy. These rules have changed often, so check the current IRCC page before applying.
Apply to extend or change it before it expires. If you apply in time and remain in Canada, you usually keep your current status and can keep working under the same conditions while IRCC decides. If your permit has already expired, you may still be able to restore your status within 90 days, but you cannot work until the restoration is approved. Do not leave Canada while relying on maintained status without advice first, because leaving can end it.
Generally you need a new work permit, or an approved change, before you start working for a new employer on an employer-specific permit. Working for an employer not named on your permit can lead to a finding that you breached your conditions, which affects future applications. If that has already happened, get advice before you file anything else.
Not automatically. A work permit is temporary, but authorized Canadian work experience can count toward permanent residence programs such as the Canadian Experience Class. Work done without a valid permit, or outside your permit’s conditions, does not count and can harm later applications. See permanent residence.
This page is general information, not legal advice about your situation.
Sources
- canada.ca: Temporary
- canada.ca: Refusal
- canada.ca: Changes open work permits family members temporary residents
- canada.ca: Help your spouse common law partner work canada
- canada.ca: Eligibility
- canada.ca: Check processing times
- ircc.canada.ca: Fees.asp
- www12.statcan.gc.ca: 98 200 x2021001 eng.cfm
- canada.ca: Eligibility
- laws-lois.justice.gc.ca: Section 72
- laws-lois.justice.gc.ca: Section 40
- canada.ca: Officer decision notes
- fct-cf.ca: Who may represent you in an immigration refugee protection or citizenship matter in federal court